
Phil Plummer, Head Winemaker at Montezuma Winery & Idol Ridge Winery
How’d you get into winemaking?
“I went to university at RIT, with the intention of pursuing a career in biotech, computer science, or some combination of the two. Early in my freshman year I learned that the wine tasting classes offered through the hospitality program were open to everybody and that if you took them you could taste wines even if you were under 21. I signed up immediately and fell in love with wine. I started my own experiments with winemaking and brewing in my college apartment, but I didn’t see that for the career path that it was until I took a part-time job at a local winery. Once I understood that I could make a living making wine, I changed my major, graduated as quickly as possible, and started working in winemaking full-time. 16 years later, I’m even more excited about wine and winemaking than I was when I started.”
What do you enjoy most about winemaking?
“The most exciting aspect of any art form is the chance to bring abstract ideas into physical existence, and winemaking is no exception. Every wine we make is a unique opportunity to evaluate and refine our ideas about nature, beauty, tradition, time, and place, and we get to watch those ideas manifest as a living product that we can share with others. It’s a revelatory process that never gets old.”
What is your philosophy and inspiration behind creating our wines?
“I like to color outside the lines, but in a way that highlights the lines so it’s obvious that I’m aware of them and stepping outside intentionally. I’m a student of winemaking history and tradition, and what I really love is taking classic wine styles and techniques and applying them in very novel, unconventional ways.”
Just for fun, what do you listen to while creating in the cellar?
“I’m always listening to something while working in the cellar. Usually, it’s a podcast; current events, history, comedy, and true crime are some of my favorite genres. Occasionally, I’ll find conversation to be distracting, so I switch to music – mostly indie hip-hop and rock.”